Wednesday, October 5, 2022
HomeFoodQuiche Lorraine Recipe Showdown | Kitchn

Quiche Lorraine Recipe Showdown | Kitchn


Once I was rising up, my mom labored part-time in a tea store, the place she made quiche after quiche day after day. She was identified round city as “the quiche girl” and I used to be incessantly fortunate sufficient to eat a slice or two. Through the years, I’ve eaten quiche from French cafés and made a lot of my very own, and I proceed to like the dish for its all-day attraction. Let’s simply say that I’ve ideas about quiche.

If I say the phrase quiche, what’s the following phrase you consider? Most individuals promptly reply “Lorraine,” arguably the preferred type of the dish. Named after a area in France, quiche Lorraine initially mixed salty pork like lardons or bacon with a easy egg custard in a pastry shell. Because the years glided by, cooks added onions and cheese to the combo to make the quiche Lorraine we all know immediately.

When choosing my high contenders for this quiche Lorraine head-to-head, I first thought of what qualifies as a quiche Lorraine. Clearly it required a backside crust and an egg and dairy custard in addition to bacon, pancetta, or lardons. A lot of the choices I checked out additionally contained the attribute onions and Swiss or generally Gruyère cheese, however contemplating the dish’s roots, I didn’t make these components a strict requirement. Personally, I like a clean, creamy custard with savory bacon taste and a crisp crust. It also needs to have a pleasant stability of textures and flavors.

Meet Our 4 Quiche Lorraine Contenders

After contemplating what I used to be searching for, I did my analysis. I appeared to the web, cookbooks, family and friends — wherever and in every single place which may have quiche intel. I wished all traditional recipes, nothing too far outdoors of what we’d all agree is a quiche Lorraine, however with some distinct variations.

Le Ache Quotidien’s Quiche Lorraine is full of ham, cheese, and slow-cooked leeks, and the filling is thick and creamy, because of loads of bitter cream. It’s a wealthy one. That is the one recipe that doesn’t require you to par-bake the crust, which was interesting from a time-saving standpoint.

Betty Crocker’s Quiche Lorraine skips cooking the onions and as a substitute has you add finely chopped uncooked onion on to the quiche. Whereas much less complicated, it provides a pleasant texture and saves time. That is the best of all 4 — particularly when you skip the home made shortening crust.

Julia Little one’s Quiche Lorraine leaves off the onion and cheese, leading to a minimalist dish. Would the simplicity of the recipe — and the magic that’s Julia — assist this one rise to the highest?

Vallery Lomas’ Quiche Lorraine makes use of a home made or store-bought pie crust and bakes it in a cake or springform pan, which was intriguing. The quiche appeared and sounded scrumptious, like an elevated however straightforward model of the traditional.

How I Examined the Quiche Lorraine Recipes

I made one quiche at a time, two the primary day and two the following. I used the identical all-purpose unbleached flour and natural eggs for every, in addition to the identical bacon and the identical Swiss cheese (the place known as for). Whereas I used to be tempted to make use of Gruyère in Lomas’ recipe (which affords just a few cheese choices within the ingredient record), I didn’t need to be swayed by that ingredient swap. I imply, I actually like Gruyère cheese, so there’s an opportunity her quiche would have gained based mostly on that alone.

I tasted every quiche after cooling for a number of minutes, then once more as soon as they have been at room temperature.

1. The Greatest Crust: Le Ache Quotidien’s Quiche Lorraine

The French fast-casual chain’s quiche Lorraine takes a maximalist method with ham, Swiss cheese, and caramelized leeks and onions. I discovered it a bit too wealthy and busy for my style, however I’m saving the crust recipe. It’s straightforward and doesn’t require blind baking however nonetheless finally ends up splendidly crisp.

2. The Best: Betty Crocker’s Quiche Lorraine

Betty Crocker will be counted on for the classics, and quiche Lorraine is a traditional. This straightforward recipe skips cooking the onions, choosing finely chopped uncooked onions as a substitute. The result’s candy bits of onion which have misplaced their uncooked chew however nonetheless have a little bit of crunch. Loads of bacon and cheese do their half to create a tasty quiche. The one draw back was the home made shortening crust recipe, which lacks taste and didn’t crisp in addition to I’d hoped.

3. For the Purist: Julia Little one’s Quiche Lorraine

On the subject of traditional French meals, you may’t go mistaken with Julia Little one. This recipe is extra conventional, leaving out the onions and cheese. It’s baked in a tart pan as a substitute of a pie pan and requires just some principal components: eggs, cream, and bacon. The ensuing quiche is not like another on this record — as a substitute of being crammed with flavorful onions and cheese and meat, the main target is on the eggs and cream, punctuated by salty bacon. 

It’s creamy and custardy and type of dreamy, nevertheless it may not fulfill you when you’re searching for the quiche Lorraine we all know and love immediately.

4. The Clear Winner: Vallery Lomas’ Quiche Lorraine

Lomas’ quiche has all the key parts: a creamy custard, sautéed onions, crispy bacon, and melty cheese. By baking it in a cake pan, the crust will get good and crisp and creates extra room for the filling. Lomas graciously contains loads of methods to tweak the recipe — together with utilizing a store-bought pie crust — which makes the dish particularly versatile. 

This quiche Lorraine ticks all the packing containers. It’s an elevated model of the traditional dish nevertheless it’s not overly difficult. It’s a simple recipe to make that produces superior outcomes, and is bound to steal the highlight at your subsequent brunch, lunch, or dinner.

Laurel Randolph


Laurel is a meals author, recipe developer, and editor. She is the writer of 4 cookbooks, one in all which was a #2 best-seller of 2017.




Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments